--- title: California Wildfires Highlight Wireless Vulnerabilities by Alan Hearty description: Learn how the California wildfires affected wireless services, and what lessons can be gleaned from the disaster recovery. image: https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hubfs/CalWireless%20Law%20Blog%20Images/CalWireless%20Law.png --- [![](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Allen_Matkins_October2017-theme/Images/allenmatkinslogo.png?width=275&height=49&name=allenmatkinslogo.png "allenmatkinslogo.png")](http://allenmatkins.com/) Contact us with your California wireless law questions [here](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/contact-us-0) # [![](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hubfs/Misc.%20Banners/calwireless-banner.jpg) California Wireless Law Blog](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com) - [Home](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com) - [Contact Us](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/contact-us-0) # California Wildfires Highlight Wireless Vulnerabilities by Alan Hearty ![Picture of Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hubfs/Alan%20Hearty.jpg) Posted on February 07, 2019 by [Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/author/alan-hearty) In a previous installment, we discussed the issues associated with resilience in the nation’s wireless networks, particularly in connection with recovery after disaster situations such as hurricanes. Continuing that discussion, we will examine how the recent California wildfires affected wireless services, and what lessons can be gleaned as recovery from the disaster continues. ![Image of California Wildfires](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/California%20Wireless%20Law%20Blog%20Wireless%20Vulnerabilities%20Alan%20Hearty.jpg?width=1080&name=California%20Wireless%20Law%20Blog%20Wireless%20Vulnerabilities%20Alan%20Hearty.jpg) ## Vulnerabilities Mobile Services Face Mobile service sometimes falls short of traditional landlines in terms of surviving emergencies and disaster events. Some common [vulnerabilities](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-17/phones-fail-in-california-fires-highlighting-vulnerability) that mobile service infrastructures face include: - Winds or fires often destroy cell towers and other [wireless installations](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/pacific-grove-votes-allow-wireless-installation-alan-hearty) - Batteries and other power supplies can run out during emergencies - Lines that run from towers to the network are sometimes cut during disaster recovery - Many cell sites do not have backup power; rental space for backup equipment can be expensive and permits for storing fuel can be difficult to obtain - Some cell sites may also not support backup equipment logistically (such as when a [5G wireless](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/fcc-5g-wireless-technology-proposal-alan-hearty) installation is placed in a rooftop location) In the specific case of the California wildfires, a majority of the service interruptions in the state were the result of underground fiber lines being damaged or burned. Fiber being mounted on poles that burned down also resulted in service interruptions. ## Bolstering Wireless Resiliency While cell phone service was badly affected on account of the wildfires, they do demonstrate some degree of recovery and [resiliency](http://www.calcorporatelaw.com/2010/06/adspirat-primo-fortuna-labori)based on several significant factors. For instance, many phone companies can make use of portable cell towers that can be moved into affected zones as needed. The use of power backups can also greatly benefit wireless networks in a disaster situation (though, as mentioned this may be associated with additional costs that wireless carriers must bear). Other efforts that can help speed wireless recovery include various fee waivers offered by carriers for services associated with affected phone lines. The California Public Utilities Commission has also proposed [similar fee waivers](http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/cpucblog.aspx?id=6442458433&blogid=1551) to provide relief for wildfire victims. Some wireless providers also provide free phones for affected people in such instances. While some of these measures can provide retroactive relief for persons already affected by disasters, additional strategies are needed to help prevent damage from occurring in the first place. ## Wireless Emergency Alert System (WEA) Not Utilized for the California Wildfires A main issue that arose in connection with the California wildfires was an apparent lack of the use of the [Wireless Emergency Alert System](https://www.fcc.gov/consumers/guides/wireless-emergency-alerts-wea) (WEA). The system was launched in 2012, to provide cell phone users with Amber Alert-style text messages to warn the public about situations like dangerous weather conditions or other disaster conditions. It is not clear whether the WEA system alerts could have actually saved lives in the California wildfires, on account of how fast the fire spread. What is clear, however, is that the situation clearly shows a lack of preparedness and understanding of the system. A [recent report](https://www.sfchronicle.com/news/article/Sonoma-County-emergency-readiness-warnings-fell-12709628.php)showed that local county emergency managers demonstrated “limited awareness and understanding of the WEA system and outdated information regarding WEA’s technical capabilities.” Furthermore, “checklists or detailed procedures for deciding what warnings to issue, when, and in what form appeared to be almost entirely absent. ” Thus, it appears that county officials may not have been able to send out effective warnings in a timely manner due to lack of preparation. Sonoma County officials also reported that they chose not to use the WEA alerts because they feared the system would contact cell phones far away from the fires. They were concerned about potentially creating a panic and causing additional traffic jams in evacuation zones and routes. As mentioned in our previous blog post, proposed improvements to [emergency alert geotargeting standards](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/fcc-emergency-alert-geotargeting-alan-hearty) would indeed further improve the accuracy and efficiency of the alerts during actual emergency situations. A lesson to be learned here is that in the future, perhaps earlier deployment of WEA alerts can help local residents prepare themselves for possible fires and other inclement conditions. For instance, alert messages can be used to inform people when conditions are extremely dry, increasing the risk of a wildfire. Also, the situation highlights the need for better understanding of the mechanics of the WEA system for county officials. In the meantime, carriers, wireless providers, power supply companies, and local municipalities should coordinate with one another more efficiently. This should be done both in preparation for emergencies, as well as during recovery efforts. These important groups should continue to strive to ensure citizens have access to wireless services when they are most needed. ## About the Author, Alan Hearty [Alan Hearty](https://www.allenmatkins.com/Professionals/Hearty-Alan/Biography.aspx?__hstc=72335436.722bcb457a060eff3a3775f6776b45b7.1547579328781.1547579328781.1549559765109.2&__hssc=72335436.1.1549559765109&__hsfp=1228042230) is a partner in Allen Matkins' Century City office and leads the firm's Telecommunications Infrastructure Group. Alan's practice focuses on real estate litigation and complex commercial litigation. Share on: - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) [Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/alan-hearty) [FCC Re-examines Wireless Resiliency Framework by Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/fcc-re-examines-wireless-resiliency-framework-by-alan-hearty) [Overview of the FCC’s 5G FAST Plan by Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/overview-fccs-5g-fast-plan-alan-hearty) ### Related Articles [Tensions Over Huawei Escalate With Commerce Department Trade Restrictions](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/huawei-commerce-department-trade-restrictions) [FCC’s Latest 5G Spectrum Auction and the Call to Open the Mid-Band By Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/fccs-5g-spectrum-auction-and-call-to-open-mid-band-alan-hearty) [Minimizing the Rural Digital Divide in the Face of 5G by Alan Hearty](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/minimizing-rural-digital-divide-5g-by-alan-hearty) #### ABOUT OUR AUTHOR ![“Image](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/California%20Wireless%20Law%20Blog:%20Latest%20Updates%20and%20News.jpg?width=88&height=124&name=California%20Wireless%20Law%20Blog:%20Latest%20Updates%20and%20News.jpg "“California") Alan D. Hearty Partner at [Allen Matkins](https://www.allenmatkins.com/) (310) 788-2490  [Contact me](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/contact-us-0) [Learn More About Alan](https://www.allenmatkins.com/professionals/hearty-alan.html) Get the latest news and analysis about California Wireless law. Subscribe to our newsletter today! We respect your [email privacy](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/disclaimer) ### CATEGORIES - [Alan Hearty (39)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/alan-hearty) - [California Wireless Law (21)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/california-wireless-law) - [Cell Towers (6)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-towers) - [Regulations (4)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/regulations) - [Wireless Carriers (4)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-carriers) - [cell tower (4)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-tower) - [5G (3)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/5g) - [5G Auction (3)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/5g-auction) - [Alan D. Hearty (3)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/alan-d-hearty) - [Cellular Networks (3)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cellular-networks) - [Litigation (3)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/litigation) - [Cell Service (2)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-service) - [5G Networks (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/5g-networks) - [American tower (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/american-tower) - [Bay Area (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/bay-area) - [CalWireless (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/calwireless) - [California wildfires (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/california-wildfires) - [Cell Tower Ordinance (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-tower-ordinance) - [Digital Opportunity Fund (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/digital-opportunity-fund) - [Emergency Cell Phone Service (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/emergency-cell-phone-service) - [FCC Deregulation (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/fcc-deregulation) - [Fuel Cells (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/fuel-cells) - [Government Spectrum Valuation Act (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/government-spectrum-valuation-act) - [Green Earth Technologies (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/green-earth-technologies) - [Green Technology (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/green-technology) - [Hurricane Sandy (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/hurricane-sandy) - [ISM (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/ism) - [Job Creation Act (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/job-creation-act) - [Lucas Valley (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/lucas-valley) - [Middle Class Tax Relief (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/middle-class-tax-relief) - [REIT (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/reit) - [SF Bay Area (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/sf-bay-area) - [San Francisco (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/san-francisco) - [Shot Clock Rule (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/shot-clock-rule) - [Wireless Blog (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-blog) - [Wireless Deployment (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-deployment) - [Wireless Industry (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-industry) - [Wireless Industry News (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-industry-news) - [Wireless Infrastructure (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-infrastructure) - [cell tower construction (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-tower-construction) - [cell tower issues (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/cell-tower-issues) - [huawei (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/huawei) - [wireless cell tower (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-cell-tower) - [wireless networks (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-networks) - [wireless resiliency (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-resiliency) - [wireless spectrum (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-spectrum) - [wireless tower (1)](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/tag/wireless-tower) see all #### FACEBOOK Get the latest news and analysis about California Wireless law. Subscribe to our newsletter today! We respect your [email privacy](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/disclaimer#privacy-policy) [![Allen Matkins logo](https://www.calcorporatelaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Allen_Matkins_October2017-theme/Images/allenmatkinslogo.png)](http://www.allenmatkins.com/) Allen Matkins, founded in 1977, is a California-based law firm with more than 200 attorneys in four major metropolitan areas of California: Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego and San Francisco. Alan D. Hearty Partner at [Allen Matkins](http://www.allenmatkins.com/) (310) 788-2490 [Contact me](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/contact-us-0) - - - - #### Get the latest news and analysis about California wireless law. Subscribe to our newsletter today! *We respect your [email privacy](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/disclaimer)* Copyright © 2019 Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. All Rights Reserved Disclaimer This publication is made available by Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP for educational purposes only to convey general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you acknowledge there is no attorney-client relationship between you and Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. This publication should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney applied to your circumstances. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. [Click here for full disclaimer](https://www.calwirelesslaw.com/disclaimer/).  [Cookie Policy](https://www.allenmatkins.com/disclaimers/cookie-policy.html).  [Privacy Policy](https://www.allenmatkins.com/disclaimers/privacy-policy.html).